• Books
  • Blog
  • About Judy Black
  • Contact
Menu

Judy Black

Writing up a storm
  • Books
  • Blog
  • About Judy Black
  • Contact
Big Magic by Elizabeth Gilbert

Big Magic by Elizabeth Gilbert

Friday Review: Big Magic by Elizabeth Gilbert

October 23, 2015

I was thrilled when Big Magic: Creative Living Beyond Fear by Elizabeth Gilbert was released. It arrived on my doorsteps in all its hardback gorgeousness and I dove right in, reading the whole thing over the course of two days during a vacation. Eat, Pray, Love never hit me with the magic that it affected so many other people with but I fell in love with Gilbert's Ted Talk about muses and creativity. 

The first time I heard her talk, I rolled my eyes and snorted at her discussion of magic. It all sounded too abstract for me. The second time, I listened a little closer and found her saying a lot of things I agreed with. I don't know if I will ever 100% agree with everything she says but I do really like several of her points and I couldn't wait to have a longer chance to hear about her ideas. Big Magic is that longer discussion I was waiting for. 

Gilbert believes in both the magic and the work of a creative life. What I found most refreshing was her belief that having a job to support your creative habit is not some shameful thing but is instead a vital and important part of the creative life. Not starving is always a nice bonus. 

It's interesting to hear about her own struggles, worries and challenges with writing. We tend to think of someone like her, who had a smash hit, as a success and that's it, but the pressure of following up on such a success could easily swallow her whole, Gilbert doesn't let it and keeps working, chasing after the ideas that touch her hand and ask to be taken along. 

My favorite story in the entire book is the idea of the rain forest story that jumped from her to Ann Patchett with a kiss. I've had a similar thing happen and at first, felt betrayed that my idea had been stolen, but the truth is, that idea was no more mine than the air I breathe. It's something I touched, loved and held onto but not something I had any claim on. 

I found Big Magic incredible reassuring about the entire creative process. No matter how analytical or practical you get about writing (or any creative endeavor) there will always be a piece of magic to it, a diving into the unknown, grasping, hoping and knowing that something is going to grab back. That's why I keep creating, the magic that bites back and holds tight to my skin, driving me to work. 

If you're looking to learn about other creative's processes, reassurance you're not crazy, or just a blunt, honest look at writing, I think Big Magic is an excellent addition to your library and a great book to grab when you need a pick me up and a reminder that to create is to commit to making (and being a part of) magic. 

You can buy Big Magic here.

In Reviews Tags Book reviews, big magic, elizabeth gilbert, Big Magic: Creative Living Beyond Fear, creative living
← The whooshing sound of deadlinesTo Outline Or Not: 5 Ways to Plot Your Novel →

Latest Posts

Featured
I've started writing, now what?
July 14, 2026
I've started writing, now what?
July 14, 2026

I have recently had a few friends and friends of friends jump into writing, falling in love with storytelling, and the process of getting words on page. It’s been wonderful to see. It’s also made me realize that there is still a lot of confusion out there about how the process works. So here are a few tips and information based on those conversations with people just starting out. 

Read more →
July 14, 2026
How Do You Know You’re Done Editing Something
July 8, 2026
How Do You Know You’re Done Editing Something
July 8, 2026

At what point do you actually call a project totally done and stop adjusting it?

Honestly, for me, the answer is often never. Even projects I’ve published and put out in the world, I occasionally poke at and make changes years after they were published. It isn’t always changes that I then republish, but more just things that I change for my own copy. Which isn’t really a helpful answer, is it? 

Read more →
July 8, 2026
Celebrate and Rest
March 17, 2026
Celebrate and Rest
March 17, 2026

A lot of creative work is completing things and no one ever knowing. Getting through a rough draft? Well, no one is going to really see it. Finished revising a tricky chapter? Cool! No one will probably see that work; they’ll just enjoy the full project. And a lot of times, creative work has multiple steps, so completing one just means more to do, always and forever more things piling up. 

So, what do you do? Keep running on the treadmill of non-stop work? 

Gross no. 

Read more →
March 17, 2026
Putting Story into Combat in Your DnD Game
February 18, 2026
Putting Story into Combat in Your DnD Game
February 18, 2026

Combat is honestly one thing I feel the weakest in as a DM. Running all the different monsters, tracking status effects, and abilities can absolutely turn into a slog quickly if I let it, so I have tried to add in story moments to every fight within reason. 

Read more →
February 18, 2026
Social Media and Sanity
February 3, 2026
Social Media and Sanity
February 3, 2026

Lately, I have been limiting my time on social media a lot. Which has been hard and sad. I have a lot of wonderful friends I met through the internet, and that I can only talk to online. I still spend a decent bit of time on Discord in more controlled small groups, but I’m even limiting time there and trying to just find other ways to fill my time. 

Read more →
February 3, 2026
8000 Tabs Open
November 6, 2025
8000 Tabs Open
November 6, 2025

Currently, I feel very 'death by a thousand papercuts' when it comes to my creative life. 

No longer can you be the reclusive hermit who appears only to deliver new work and then vanishes away into the lab to tinker away. And honestly, that gets super overwhelming. 

Between my day job, creative work, administrative work for the creative work, general life stuff, and everything else, I have between 40 and 60 things on my to-do list almost every day. 

Read more →
November 6, 2025
June2025WordCount.png
June 30, 2025
Writing in Chaos
June 30, 2025
Read more →
June 30, 2025
5 Horror TTRPGs for a Spine-Chilling Halloween Adventure
October 6, 2023
5 Horror TTRPGs for a Spine-Chilling Halloween Adventure
October 6, 2023

Explore spine-chilling adventures this Halloween with our top 5 horror RPG recommendations. Dive into terrifying tabletop experiences perfect for the spooky season. Discover the best role-playing games to send shivers down your spine!

Read more →
October 6, 2023
Brain Overload
August 3, 2022
Brain Overload
August 3, 2022
Read more →
August 3, 2022
July 20, 2022
The Importance of Support Networks
July 20, 2022
Read more →
July 20, 2022

Powered by Squarespace